Don Julio tequila was founded by Don Julio González in 1942 and is a legendary brand with widespread awareness.

About a decade ago, I would have told you Don Julio’s aged expressions were among my favorites. But after a lengthy education on quality tequila, I was eager to revisit this back-bar staple to see how it still holds up.

At face value, there is a lot to like about Don Julio.

They cook Highland agave in traditional stone/brick ovens for about 48 hours, crush with a roller mill, ferment in stainless steel tanks, and distill in stainless steel pot stills with copper coils. So far, these production methods are consistent with those used for many well-crafted tequilas.

The añejo is aged for 18+ months in American white oak casks that previously held bourbon—at least six months longer than the category’s required minimum.

The bottle offers up a distinctive shape, quality presentation, and strong brand recognition, and it’s readily available everywhere from grocery stores to your local bar.

While Don Julio seems interested in delivering a smooth and accessible luxury tequila, not all is smooth in the news surrounding the brand and its parent company, Diageo.

Lawsuits have questioned whether all the fermentable sugars used to make the tequila come from agave. Critics cry foul, while Diageo denies the allegations. I’m no lawyer, and I don’t run a testing laboratory, so I’ll stay away from authenticity claims and focus on what I taste.

Aroma: Strong vanilla, cherry, oak, orange peel, alcohol, wet earth, and smoke.

Flavor: Strong vanilla, plenty of bitter oak, black pepper, alcohol, cinnamon, clove, and whiskey.

Finish: An initial, almost effervescent tingle that ends with bitter oak, leather, and a sweet aftertaste.

I can see why someone used to inexpensive tequila meant for cocktails or shots might gravitate toward Don Julio as a step up into sipping neat or on the rocks. I did over a decade ago.

But this añejo is too sweet for my palate, with bitter oak and an alcohol bite. There are plenty of options on the market for a nice sipping añejo.

NOM

1449

Agave

Jalisco (Los Altos)

Cooking

Stone or brick oven

Extraction

Roller Mill

Water

Deep well water

Fermentation

Stainless steel tanks

Still

Stainless pot with copper coil

Age

18+ months in American white oak bourbon casks

ABV

40%

Tequila Report Score: 78

78 points out of 100 (3.9 out of 5 points)

Price $64.99

More from Don Julio: All of our Don Julio coverage, including reviews, lists, scores, and more.